Open-source users, companies scoff at Microsoft threats

Secured Funding's Lindsay said that Microsoft's reluctance to publicly disclose which patents are being violated shows it may not have as strong a case as it would like the industry to believe. He said since the Unix code on which Linux is based preceded Windows, Microsoft may have actually patented technologies in Linux that previously existed, and so those patents would be deemed invalid by the courts.

Lindsay, Zemlin and others also said they believe Microsoft is exploiting the patent system in the U.S. to buy time as it tries to compete in an industry where it is no longer a thought leader. The company has held on to its traditional business model of selling software licenses too long as new, more successful business models -- such as providing software for free and earning revenue on services, and selling ads to support online services -- have emerged, they said. Now the company is scrambling to catch up and hopes collecting license fees on patented technology will be a successful business model in the interim.

Lindsay cited open-source projects and companies such as Google as the sources of most innovation in the last several years, and said Microsoft has been too slow to adopt new business models other companies have used to move the technology industry forward. "Their business model is fundamentally changing and Microsoft is using the courthouse to extend their old way of doing business," he said.

Zemlin was more blunt, calling Microsoft's "posturing" as "empty threats from a scared giant whose monopoly is being challenged."

Charles Merriam, an independent consultant and entrepreneur who uses OpenOffice.org and Open Source Linux Desktop rather than Microsoft Office and Windows, also suggested that Microsoft is feeling the pressure from more nimble competitors, and is trying to cover its own inability to compete by attacking competitors. "It's just like with SCO Group -- when they no longer had a product to sell, it started suing people," he said. "It looks like Microsoft is throwing in the towel on trying to be innovative."

However, Merriam said that while larger companies are less likely to worry about Microsoft's threats, some startups might be afraid that the company could sink their businesses by suing for patents, and may consider moving offshore to escape possible litigation.

China Martens in Boston and Robert Mullins in San Francisco contributed to this article.